Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Womblo Womberson's avatar

Nekromantik is a film about male sexuality. Serbian film is a critique of the porn industry and of the Eastern European art film scene. Neither of them are excessively cruel.

A Serbian Film needs to be cruel because its a study of cruelty in art. Both in the ways capital drives a never ending arms race for more and more extreme content as well as the psychological tolls the production has on the performer.

Nekromantik's subject matter is inherently cruel. It couldn't get it's message across in a less cruel way because of how necessary the body and more specifically the image of the corpse is to the film. The film's going into detail about how the process of objectification as a dehumanising process which stripes the other subject of itself in order to generate fantasy, drawing out the violence of that psychological process using the dead body as a centerpiece. Off the top my head I don't know how'd you'd dance around the nekro in nekromantik without just not making it.

These films are far from flawless (personally I myself am not a big fan of Serbian Film) and ultimately if they were too cruel for you that's fine but at the risk of sounding cruel I found that criticism kinda lazy. These films are both known for how extreme they are so it's easy to use them as a scapegoat for how the genre can be stereotyped. As nothing more than tasteless, pulp filth. But dismissing both of these works as nothing but "cruelty for cruelties sake" is doing the exact same thing, your dismissing a valid form of artistic expression for not matching your sensibilities which is not in keeping with the punk spirit of the horror genre at all.

If you want to talk about excessive cruelty you could talk about the ways in which that film treats the practise of cross dressing as inherently freakish? Or the way it represents disabilities? Admittedly I'm not giving TCM much credit, it is more nuanced than that but I'm making a point here, I'm sure you could find tons of examples of mainstream horror being excessively cruel but instead you jab at the fringes of foreign avant-guarde cinema.

This is a good article btw. I just like being a little hater freak. Keep up the good work if your still writing these.

Also Serbian Films a black comedy. Nekromantik has a tinge of dark humour (I mean it literally ends with him ejaculating blood clearly some level of playfulness is present here). Not that it would be a problem if they weren't. A horror film isn't required to be humours.

Expand full comment
Pedini's avatar

I had a copy of An Illustrated History of The Horror Film. Thank you for reminding me! It’s weird to see something that was so familiar at one point in my life but since forgotten.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts